The Coalition of the Swilling

Very good list, Bing, but I nominate 1991:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1991_in_music

Hmm, I see a lot of power chords in that list Cullen..why am I not surprised?

Unfortunately, however, I may have to ban you from our site as that list contains the name "Bryan Adams"...

October 25 - Steely Dan spontaneously reunites

That, in and of itself, is enough to ruin 1991 for me. Thank God marrying my lovely bride that same year more than makes up for this tragedy......

Right, so we can scratch off 1991, then.

So your 1979 list basically restates my point.

(Not that there's not some okay, even good, stuff on the list, but it's a very small part of the list)

Bing you're showing what a young pup you are. Almost any year from 68 to 76 trumps 79. At least it's before the big hair bands.

Back away from the 8-track, Major Dad!

8 track my ass! VINYL, baby!

If he backed away Bing, he may trip over the Betamax...or slip on a Laser Disc.

I believe that the good that is in 1991 trumps any of the bad. And 1992 is almost as good. Any music prior was merely to pave the way for the great music that happened thereafter.

Tho' I will throw a shout out to my birthyear 1974 for producing The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway and King Crimson's Starless and the Bible Black.

And I just tried to trackback.

thanks cullen, fixed it!

Ah yes, King Crimson with Greg Lake, later of ELP, one of my favorite groups. And Ken, I must agree, music was made for Vinyl. CDs are handy, but vinyl is what music sounds best on. Drives the CAG up the wall that I still have the old GE cabinet stereo, just so I can play 78s.... as the thing ways a ton.

Well, it's not like there was no good music that year. Much of it blew chunks though, at least as far as I'm concerned. The number one song? My Sharona. 1979 also gave us the nightmare titled YMCA.

The humanity.

Heheheheh. 1979 also gave us Steely Dan's "Gaucho." But as Mr. Fagen said himself on that very album, "We've got nothin' in common; We can't talk at all..."

"I believe that the good that is in 1991 trumps any of the bad. And 1992 is almost as good."

Aww. They're so cute when they're little!

Look, Ken, just because I wasn't there when God called music into being, doesn't mean that I can't appreciate the intelligent way in which it has evolved.

Aw, don't let Ken get to you Cullen; he hasn't been able to figure out how to work record players since they lost the cranks in the front.

This popped up in Sheila's comments on her post about albums. Way too cool.

Cranks? They put cranks on them now?

Yeah, I was thinking of ordering one on amazon, but it says they don't know when they're shipping.

Youngsters

1972
Harvest - Neil Young
Machine Head - Deep Purple
Led Zeppelin IV - Led Zeppelin
Hot Rocks 1964-1971 - Rolling Stones
Madman Across The Water - Elton John
Eat A Peach - Allman Brothers Band
Fragile - Yes
Argus - Wishbone Ash
The Rise & Fall Of Ziggy Stardust & The Spiders From Mars - David Bowie
Black Sabbath Vol. 4 - Black Sabbath

BTW, I have all of these. Bet many of you have never heard Argus.

I think Mr Bingley is correct - 1979 was a sea-change year in music, that killed forever the disco shit.

Some other seminal classics from that year were:-

XTC - Drums & Wires
Marianne Faithful - Broken English
Neil Young - Rust Never Sleeps
The Motels - The Motels

Without 1979, music today would be something totally different....

1972 was a good year - but I'd go with 1971.
American Pie - Don McLean
Anticipation - Carly Simon
Aqualung - Jethro Tull
Blue - Joni Mitchell
Every Picture Tells a Story - Rod Stewart
L.A. Woman - The Doors
Tapestry - Carole King
Tarkus - Emerson, Lake & Palmer
Tea for the Tillerman - Cat Stevens
The Low Spark of High Heeled Boys - Traffic
The Yes Album - Yes
Who's Next - The Who

Kathy K,

I almost went with 1973 because it has two of my all-time faves: Deep Purple's Made in Japan and The Who's Quadrophenia.

71 was a good year, too. Tapestry, Who's Next, and Tea for the Tillerman are great albums. Other than Fragile, Yes doesn't do it for me. I bought Close to the Edge and Relayer after Fragile. They are pristine 30yr old albums now because they have only been played twice each. Once was enough.

BTW, you now can't work for Rolling Stone Magazine, either.

I have to change my vote to 1973. Add Wishbone Ash's Live Dates to the two I mentioned earlier (Made in Japan and Quadrophenia) and that's three of my desert island albums. Can't ignore that.

Rob - I see the flaw in your plan; you should have went earlier with the Yes, not later. The Yes Album is wonderful. "Starship Troopers" may be my favorite song of theirs. (Liked Close to the Edge too, but wasn't so enamored of Relayer.)

As much as I crack on the Boomers, I have to admit that their music has an edge over my own generation. A breakdown of my post-college holdings reveals a Clapton album, a Yes album, two each by U2 and Steely Dan, and the great bulk of the remainder are imports.

Thanks all for bolstering my argument to the musically challenged Bing. By the way Yes does do it for me, have to have seen them in concert and I was sober, sort of, all 6 or 7 times I saw them.

Finally, finally, FINALLY!

The adults have finally joined the thread.

I don't have a particular year I like over the others, but '71, '72, and '73 were all good years.

I will admit, though, that kaboom makes a very good point in favor of '79. Now if only disco would stay dead.

I haven't ever heard a Yes Album I didn't like - though I'll admit I did like Fragile best.

I could make a reasonably good case for 1970 too...
After the Gold Rush - Neil Young
Bridge Over Troubled Water - Simon & Garfunkel
Deja Vu - Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young
Emerson, Lake and Palmer - Emerson, Lake & Palmer
(and more...)

I think you nailed it! 1979 was my first real awakening to music and to this day I rave about Cheap Trick "Live at Budokan", Blondie's "Eat to the Beat", Clash "London Calling" and The Wall. Excellent!

Uzz, my friend, you are going to go far in this world!