And While We’re At It, James Caan Should Have NEVER Been Sonny Corleone


Burt Reynolds, baby.

All the way.

Rankles to this day.
ths update:
Rob. You’re kidding me…


10 Responses to “And While We’re At It, James Caan Should Have NEVER Been Sonny Corleone”

  1. Clive says:

    Amen brother

  2. Rob says:

    Nahhh. Would have been too soon. Burt didn’t learn how to act until about 20 years later.

    Really, though? I thought Caan was excellent.

  3. Gunslinger says:


    James Caan did work well in “Rollerball” though.

  4. Rob says:

    No way. Look at those two guys. Which one looks like New York, New Jersey and which one looks like California/Florida? Caan is Sonny Corleone.

  5. Greg Newsom says:

    Sonny was hyperactive and impulsive, not cool. James Caan played that well. Burt
    couldn’t have played such
    an unlikeable person.
    But, maybe I’m missing this posts’ point?

  6. tree hugging sister says:

    Nope. It was meant to be a big argument, Greg, because Rob is always wrong.

  7. Rob says:

    I feel special now, ths. Thanks. I thought you said that about all the guys here. 🙂

  8. mojo says:


  9. major dad says:

    Godfather II would have been difficult to do then.

  10. mojo says:

    Nah, just use Andy Garcia for the young Vito and kiss off GF3…

Image | WordPress Themes